top of page

Top Roofing Materials for Wisconsin Homes: What Works (and What Doesn’t)

Writer: Jon Torre
Jon Torre
Feb 18
8 min read

Updated: Oct 12

Wisconsin’s weather doesn’t mess around. Between ice storms, hail, heavy snow, and high winds, your roof has to work hard. The best roofing materials aren’t always the flashiest. They’re the ones that can stand up to the Midwest’s unique climate and make financial sense for your home.


Short answer: for most Wisconsin homes, asphalt shingles are the best value, with composite as the main premium alternative; clay, slate, and wood suit specific homes.


Before you invest in a “high-end” roof that looks great in Malibu or Mallorca, but fails in Madison or Milwaukee, let’s take a look at the roofing materials for Wisconsin homes that actually perform best here, and which ones cost more than they’re worth.


Chart of roofing material cost versus lifespan, from flat roofs at about 10-28 years to slate at 70-100 years

Asphalt Shingles are Still the Most Popular Choice in Wisconsin


  • Cost: $

  • Weight: Light


Asphalt shingles (or similar technology) have been used on homes for thousands of years, and asphalt shingles themselves have been used on American homes for more than a century. They’re affordable, effective, and work well in nearly every Wisconsin neighborhood.


Pros:

  • Budget-friendly with a wide range of aesthetic options

  • Handles snow well; standard shingles are vulnerable to large hail, which is why impact-rated upgrades exist

  • The material Solstice solar shingles are designed to be installed alongside, and it also works with rack-mounted solar panels

  • Recycled at a large scale nationally, including in Dane County (see how asphalt shingle recycling works in Wisconsin)


Cons:

  • Shorter lifespan than premium materials (typically 20–30 years, newer product generations possibly longer)

  • Cannot be used on slopes below 2:12, and slopes from 2:12 to 4:12 need double underlayment (below that, flat roofing materials are required)


Pro Tip:If you want an upscale look or improved hail resistance, premium options like CertainTeed Carriage House or NorthGate ClimateFlex, both Class 4 impact-rated shingles, can add style and performance without switching to a different roofing material. Some insurers may even discount your homeowners’ premium if you select these options. Our guide to choosing roof shingles in Wisconsin breaks down which grades and impact ratings fit different budgets and roof types.



Standing Seam Metal Roofs are Long-Lasting, but not Practical


  • Cost: $$$$

  • Weight: Light


In recent years, metal roofing has been marketed as the ultimate upgrade. They are sleek, “forever” roofs that promise to outlast generations. But for most Wisconsin homeowners, the numbers simply don’t add up. The push toward metal has often had more to do with marketing and margin than with performance.


Pros:

  • Long lifespan

  • Sustainable and fully recyclable

  • Compatible with solar panels (clamp-on installations require no drilling)


Cons:

  • Can dent from large hail or falling branches (usually cosmetic, but visible)

  • Risk of rust at low points where water can collect

  • Can be noisy during storms

  • Higher upfront cost

  • Specific aesthetic may not fit the neighborhood

  • ROI realization unlikely in your lifetime


Noise is a common complaint with metal in hail and heavy rain. Our breakdown of roofing material noise levels covers what the research actually shows.

Learn more about why we don’t recommend metal roofs for most Wisconsin homeowners in our full comparison: Metal Roofing: Is It Really Worth It in Wisconsin?


Bar chart of hail and snow durability: standing seam metal 10, synthetic 8, asphalt, clay and slate 5, wood shakes 1
Scores are relative (0-10) and cover hail and snow resistance only, not lifespan or cost.

Clay Tile Roofs are Beautiful, But Not Built for Wisconsin Climate


  • Cost: $$$$

  • Weight: Very Heavy


Clay tile roofs are undeniably beautiful. They bring a warm, old-world look that’s hard to beat. But aesthetics aside, they were designed for dry, sun-drenched climates, not freeze-thaw winters. Before investing in a roof that’s more Mediterranean than Midwestern, it’s worth weighing form against function.


Pros:

  • Classic Mediterranean or Southwestern aesthetic

  • Long-lasting with proper maintenance


Cons:

  • Not built for freeze-thaw cycles

  • Can crack in Wisconsin winters, leaving you dealing with a mid-winter roof replacement

  • Extremely heavy: most Wisconsin homes aren’t designed to carry the weight

  • Expensive to repair or replace

  • Walking on them is dangerous and often results in damage


Animated clip of a person jumping onto clay roof tiles and falling through as they break
Clay tile is brittle underfoot, which is why walking on it often breaks tiles.

While adding solar panels is technically possible, it is difficult and not recommended. Brackets are required, and you’ll be covering up the look you paid so much for.


Bottom Line: Clay tiles are not a good match for Wisconsin’s structural or seasonal realities.


Slate Roofing is Elegant and Extremely Durable, But Impractical for Most


  • Cost: $$$$$$$

  • Weight: Very Heavy


Slate is often viewed as the pinnacle of roofing: elegant, timeless, and nearly indestructible. It’s also one of the most expensive and heaviest materials available. While its durability is impressive, most Wisconsin homes aren’t built for the weight or the wallet that slate demands.


Pros:

  • Can last 75–100 years

  • Fire-resistant and extremely durable


Cons:

  • Heavy and requires structural reinforcement

  • Expensive to install and repair

  • Lower-grade or thin slate can crack in freeze-thaw cycles; top-grade slate resists it

  • Quarrying and shipping natural slate has a real footprint, offset in part by a roof life that can exceed 75 years and slate that is often salvaged and reused


To give you a sense of the cost of these, Grace Episcopal on Madison’s capitol square recently replaced its slate roof in a project costing around $1.5 million.


Slate roofs are best for historic or architecturally unique homes built to handle the weight.



Asphalt shingles can mimic other materials: CertainTeed’s Presidential Shake (left) is styled after wood shakes, and Belmont (right) after natural slate.


Synthetic (Composite) Slate and Shake Roofing Can Be a Compelling Option in Wisconsin, Though It Is Hard to Source


  • Cost: $$

  • Weight: Medium


Composite roofing (also called synthetic slate, shakes, or shingles) is part of a new generation of materials that blend style and practicality. Designed to mimic the look of natural slate or wood without the maintenance headaches, they offer a compelling middle ground between affordability, aesthetics, and performance.


Pros:

  • One of the most visually striking options available 

  • Lightweight alternative to wood shakes or slate 

  • Many are rated for high impact resistance

  • Some products include recycled content (check the product’s spec sheet)

  • Wider range of color and styles not possible with natural rock or wood

  • Compatible with rack-mounted solar panel systems


Cons:

  • Can still be pricey

  • These are a newer technology so it can be difficult to find an experienced contractor


Great for homeowners who want a premium, low-maintenance look without the structural challenges of natural materials.



Wood and Cedar Shakes are Rustic and Classic, But High Maintenance


  • Cost: $$$$

  • Weight: Medium


Wood shakes have a rustic charm that connects to Wisconsin’s architectural roots. They were once the default for homes across the state. Today, they’re chosen more for heritage and curb appeal than practicality, since their beauty comes with higher maintenance and climate limitations.


Pros:

  • Warm, natural appearance

  • Modest natural insulating value

  • May be eligible for tax credits on historical properties


Cons:

  • Prone to rot, insects, moss

  • Not ideal for wet or snowy climates

  • Higher fire risk unless fire-retardant treated, and some insurers surcharge or decline wood roofs

  • Not recyclable

  • Requires special decking (skip/sheathing), making it expensive to switch in or out of this style

  • Difficult or impractical for solar installation


Best reserved for niche historical homes or homeowners who already have a compatible roof structure. Wood once covered a large share of Wisconsin homes. If your home is on (or eligible for) the National or State Register of Historic Places, or is a contributing building in a listed district, Wisconsin’s historic homeowner tax credit can cover part of the cost of approved exterior work, including roofing. You must apply and be approved before work starts, so check before you re-shingle with wood.


Aerial shot of a large commercial building showing a flat roof
Large commercial flat roof; the same membranes are used on porches and small additions.


Flat Roofs (TPO, EPDM, Modified Bitumen) are mostly for commercial applications


  • Cost: $$

  • Weight: Light


Common on commercial buildings, but also used on porches, one-story additions, bay windows, and modern flat-roof homes. Homeowners pick low-slope because it fits under second-story windows and existing rooflines, keeps additions within height limits, and makes the wall tie-in simpler.


Pros:

  • Ideal for solar panel installation in commercial applications due to easy tilt adjustment

  • Cost-effective for large surface areas

  • Can solve tricky geometry on residential additions without blocking existing windows or gutters

  • Cost-effective on small areas (e.g., porch or awning)


Cons:

  • Flat = poor drainage if not maintained or not appropriately pitched (flat doesn’t actually mean completely flat)

  • Prone to standing water and ice accumulation if drains clog

  • Requires much higher maintenance than pitched roofs (e.g., quarterly cleaning)

  • Often not ideal for solar in residential applications because these flat roofs are usually shaded by taller areas of the home.

  • Vulnerable to problems at transition zones (e.g., siding, chimney, edges), especially if flashing is sloppy


Small flat roof over a doorstep with failed drainage, where water is likely leaking in through the siding
Example of a small flat roof in a residential context. This one is over a doorstep in Madison’s Maple Bluff neighborhood where the drainage has failed and water is likely leaking into the house through the siding.

Asphalt-Mimicking Metal Shingles are Uncommon in Wisconsin, and Still Expensive


  • Cost: $$$

  • Weight: Light


For homeowners who love the look of traditional shingles but want the longevity of metal, asphalt-mimicking metal shingles promise the best of both worlds. They’re designed to blend in while offering improved durability, though their higher price tag and limited local installer base still make them a niche choice in most Wisconsin neighborhoods. If you are intrigued by this premium option, we recommend you look into composite or even solar roofing, instead.


Pros:

  • Offers durability of metal with the traditional look of shingles

  • More impact-resistant than standard asphalt


Cons:

  • Uncommon in Wisconsin, with few experienced installers

  • Prone to denting

  • Snow slides still a concern

  • More complex (and sometimes impractical) for solar installation


Best for intrepid homeowners who want a long-lasting roof without a “barn-like” appearance.


What to Consider When Choosing Roofing Materials for Wisconsin Homes


Before choosing a material, consider the following:


  • Roof slope: Not all materials perform well on low-slope roofs

  • Tree coverage: Frequent debris may clog gutters or damage softer materials

  • Neighborhood/HOA restrictions: Some communities regulate roof material and appearance.

  • Siding type: For example, if you have wood siding, you may be expected to use wood roofing

  • Historic designations: May limit your ability to change materials

  • Solar Plans: Some materials work better with solar than others


Infographic comparing roofing materials by maintenance, weight, cost, and recyclability


How to Avoid Roofing Scams When Choosing Roofing Material


Choosing the right material is difficult, in part because out-of-state or unreputable contractors might push you in a direction that's not right for you or your Wisconsin home. Roof replacement customers, because of the high project dollar amount, are prime targets for high-pressure contractors who push unnecessary upgrades or disappear after the deposit clears. Before you sign anything, read up on roofing and solar scams common in Wisconsin so you know what to watch for before a salesperson shows up at your door.


Our Recommendation: Start With Asphalt, Then Explore Premium Upgrades


There’s a reason asphalt shingles are still the default choice for most Wisconsin homes. They work.

But if you’re aiming for long-term durability or a premium aesthetic, consider premium asphalt (Class 4 impact-rated lines) or composite. And if solar is in your plans, asphalt is the best fit for roof-integrated solar shingles, and both asphalt and composite work with rack-mounted panels. CertainTeed’s new Landmark PWR solar shingle also works with composite.



Not sure what roofing material is right for your home? Schedule a free inspection or call 608-608-1082 and we’ll walk you through the options based on your home, your goals, and your budget.


Want to See Roofing Materials in Person?


If you want to compare different roofing materials side by side, you can experience them in person at our new office at 115 Enterprise Dr in Verona. Read about our move to Verona.


bottom of page